Wednesday, October 9, 2013

Military Death Benefits Restored [Update: Senate Balks]

The House has passed a measure to restore standard death benefits to the military.  The benefits had come to a halt after the Pentagon Comptroller's interpretation of the continuing resolution for the Defense Department, the Pay Our Military Act, despite the clear instructions of the House leadership. 

The bill passed on a unanimous vote, 425-0, and now heads to the Senate.  Baring any further political machinations, the bill will be quickly passed and sent to the President for signature.
 
Defense Secretary Hagel, Army Secretary McHugh observe return of PFC Cody Patterson
 
As further insurance, Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel announced that the Fisher House Foundation, among some others, has agreed to finance the benefits until such time as the Pentagon can reimburse it. 

Obama has directed the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and White House lawyers to craft a solution to the problem before the end of the day.  Left unexplained is, after this problem has percolated for several days, why the President waited until now to act.

The start of this financial and emotional quagmire began with the announcement by Pentagon Comptroller Robert Hale on 5 October that "Unfortunately, we don't have the legal authority to make those payments", which referred to the emergency death benefits of $100,000 accruing to a family for immediate needs, as well as further payments to cover other costs such as travel and funeral expenses. 

The House leadership immediately declared that the Comptroller drew too fine a distinction, not to mention a stupefying one, about a settlement that had already been agreed to.  The death benefits were specifically addressed during the discussion about the POMA, with Speaker Boehner saying that the Pentagon had "broad authority" to include the benefits. 

Representative Buck McKeon (R-California), Chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, said "Judging by the Department of Defense's own summary of those programs, we believed that 'death gratuities' would continue to go to the families of those heroes who made the ultimate sacrifice." [emphasis mine] 

In what I hope is a reply directly to Mr Hale, Secretary Hagel said, "I am offended, outraged and embarrassed that the government shutdown had prevented the Department of Defense from fulfilling this most sacred responsibility in a timely manner."

*****
Update: There is no evidence that the Senate is going to take up the bill now that the Fisher House Foundation has agreed to cover the costs.  Will reporters be hounding Harry Reid about that?  (Not bloody likely.)  Would he have the same attitude about this that he does about children with cancer?

*****
Update: As the days have gone by, it is now obvious that Harry Reid has no intention of allowing the Senate to vote on the bill.
 

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Death Benefits For Families of Military Fallen Shut Down

Five American warriors have been struck down within the last few days in Afghanistan: a Marine, LCpl Jeremiah Collins, Jr, whose death is under investigation, and four members assigned to B Company, 3rd Battalion, 75th Rangers – SGT Patrick Hawkins and PFC Cody Patterson of the Rangers, 1LT Jennifer Moreno of the Cultural Support Team attached to the unit, and Special Agent Joseph Peters of Army CID, 5th MP Battalion. 

The four soldiers were struck down in a mission against an insurgent plot to attack an Afghan official, in the Zhari district near Kandahar.  Initial casualties were sustained when a platoon attacked the objective only to have enemy pre-set charges command detonated. As troops responded to the scene, at least one suicide attack detonated in their midst.  Early reports indicated at least four enemy KIA but have recently specified that the number of enemy killed and wounded is unknown.  Besides our four soldiers killed, some 30 were wounded, making this a Mass Casualty event, a dreaded but rare occurrence.  Ironically, one of the more notable Mass-Cas events occurred with this same unit, B/3/75, when they fought their way out of the Blackhawk Down incident in Mogadishu in 1993.
 
Cody Patterson on the left, his final companion to the right
 
This news hits our family personally in several ways, though we were perversely fortunate that it was not directly.  We knew Cody Patterson, though not intimately, but our children have been friends with him and his siblings.  Captain of the football team, he was a popular guy, elected "Mr Philomath High School" as a fundraiser for a children's hospital, and he volunteered to teach wilderness skills to children during the summer, alongside one of his friends – my son.  That son of mine is now engaged in his final act of comradeship: a member of the same deployed battalion of Rangers, he is escorting Cody home.  Another son at Fort Hood is trying to make it back here to meet them. 

As a community in this small town, as most small towns will do, we are reaching out to each other to make this final journey what it should be, and I and my family have been busy with all the others today. 

Imagine my bitter shock to find that death benefits to our soldiers are being withheld due to the shutdown.  A previous bill from the Republicans in the House to fully fund the military during this political showboat was passed through the Senate and signed by Obama, and that should have taken care of the problem.  But this morning an unnamed "Pentagon official" announced that the interpretation of the bill from another unnamed budgeteer holds that death benefits and reimbursements cannot be paid to the families of the deceased. 

Within moments, Democrats took to the microphones to hang this on the Republicans.  A less cynical person than I would interpret this as another political opportunity to make this shutdown "as painful as possible" in order to score points in a most despicable way.
 
The interpretation hinges on the idea that the bill approved pay to active members of the military, but not to their families.  Republicans such as Speaker Boehner and Representative Buck McKeon (R-California) said that it was the clear intent of the bill to include death benefits.  After all, wouldn't it be a consideration that the payment would be to the estate of the deceased?  Some news reports state that the House was "warned", but Boehner and others said that this discussion was prior to the event and the subject of death benefits was specifically addressed.  Part of the outrage stems from the fact that some bureaucratic drones have ambushed this situation in what amounts to them telling Congress, which makes the laws, what the law should mean despite the clear direction from the lawmakers.

Specifically curtailed is an immediate $100,000 payment to the family to cover funeral and associated expenses, as well as all accrued and unpaid income and allowances. Additionally affected are expenses for travel to Dover AFB in Delaware (where all of our fallen are processed) to meet the remains and accompany them; cost of funeral expenses such as memorial services, caskets, and the like; and travel expenses for families to the bedsides of severely wounded servicemembers in US military hospitals in Germany. 

This needs to be fixed – now.  Waiting for the politicians to solve the overall budget problem will not help PFC Patterson's family, and the families of the other fallen comrades, who need this blithering obstacle removed.  They are dealing with too much already to have this bureaucratic insanity attack them.
 
Contact your Representatives and Senators.  Raise holy Hell.
 

Friday, October 4, 2013

Shutdown Kabuki (Update: Obama Golf Course Still Open)

I have returned from the wilderness, from Wheeler Ridge and Angel's Perch, and from no less a wilderness than Las Vegas (though only as a caravansary), to find another rendition of grand political theatre in the form of the government shutdown.

                                                                                           (Morgan) 

Several sources have asked for my observations on how this is to unfold, and its impact.  The questions remind me that it has been some time since the last political show, that being in 1996, though we have come close a few times since.  In fact, this marks the 18th time since 1974 that we have gone through this charade, but there has been practically a new generation that has come of voting age and awareness. 

Perhaps you have already perceived my attitude about this drama, fodder as it is for politicians and the press, which follows the script in almost breathless fashion, but the fact of the matter is that this is entirely for show. 

The last 'crisis' was marked by the MSM laying the blame on the doorstep of the Republicans, despite the fact that the GOP-led Congress passed a budget which was in turn vetoed by President Clinton.  The 1994 election had gone squarely against the Democrats, aided in most part by their back-room attempt (squired by the unelected Hillary Clinton) at bringing health care under federal control, then labeled derisively as HillaryCare.  (Is any of this starting to sound strangely familiar?)  The magnitude of the defeat was directly proportional to the subsequent effort of the Democrats and the press (but I repeat myself) to claw their way back to the top.  House Speaker Newt Gingrich was vilified at every opportunity in the most transparent ways.
 
 
 
Over a brief period of time, public perception became 2-1 against the Republicans for 'shutting down the government' despite Clinton's veto, and Republicans have been gun-shy of the tactic ever since. 

In fact, Charles C W Cooke of National Review Online provides a helpful template of the history of shutdowns: of the 17 examples, 15 of them were instigated by a Democrat-led House, eight of them when the Democrats controlled both the House and Senate, and five times when they controlled Congress and the presidency as well.  What makes this most recent budget battle unique is that Obama responds with his default position of leaving town to campaign instead of remaining to negotiate, which he makes a point of advertising, even going so far as to call the congressional actors to the White House to tell them that he will not talk to them.  Instead, he simply repeats his position by stamping "Me Too" onto whatever Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi come up with. 

Further, on a more fundamental point, Cooke answers the pundits who insist that re-electing Obama means that he can have whatever he wants:
Still, popular or not, the abject folly of making "majority rule" arguments in a system of equally ranked branches should be self-evident.  This truly is painfully simple: Republicans are the majority in the House, and the House's assent is necessary to a legal budget.  Indeed, if any of the players in the budgetary game is superior, it is the House.  Not only is it wholly wrong to pretend that the House is expected to acquiesce to the fiscal and legislative demands of the president simply because he won the last election, but it is dangerous – just one more step on the road to the imperial polity that the American system of separated powers was contrived to prevent.
Perhaps the Democrats and their pundits should peruse the Constitution to try to find somewhere in Article II where it says that the president is bestowed the powers of an emperor.  When the President submits a budget to Congress, which Obama has never successfully done, even on those few occasions when he tried (whereupon it was voted down even by the totality of the Democrats), the House acts upon it, making the necessary adjustments, only as a Constitutional courtesy.  (See Article I, Section 7, which begins with "All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills.") 

Another aspect of the shut-down tactic of this game is that the public must take note and be heedful that life without a fully functioning government should be painful.  Cuts must be made to demonstrate that.  The result of the first 'Taxpayers Revolt' in California, the 1978 Proposition 13 that rolled back the threatening and skyrocketing property taxes, resulted in the professional bureaucracy striking back with announced closures of police, fire, education, libraries – areas where the voter must feel the sting from their insolence of daring to challenge the power of the state.  That is one of the rules of the game, and it applies no less here, but now we have a broader means – more balanced news sources, talk radio, web logs – of seeing the background of the game and the plays as they unfold. 

This results in what is now a tradition called the Washington Monument Ploy, a sardonic reference to the old football Statue of Liberty Play.  It was named as such in 1969 when the director of the NPS shut down the Washington Monument and the Grand Canyon in an effort to restore funding.  The public quickly saw through this cynical tactic and, though funding was later restored, the director was forced to resign.  The nomenklatura today, though, is no longer under any such compunction to honorably correct such hubris. 

The most obvious example is the absurd theatre unfolding at the World War II Memorial in Washington DC.  In this supposed austerity suddenly thrust upon us for an unforeseen period of time, the National Park Service has been directed to have their people erect barriers around the memorial – a place that is, up till now, completely open and unmanned.  (For that matter, it is now technically illegal to set foot upon the grass of the entire mall.)  Extra personnel have been assigned to erect and watch over the barrier.  It was immensely satisfying to see the first collection of World War II veterans brought to DC, at no small expense, simply blow past the barriers in defiance of this Potemkin-like obstacle to a memorial dedicated personally to them.  The extra Park Police and National Park Service officials were flummoxed and had to resort to asking their chain of command for guidance, and one wet hen in NPS uniform, protesting the "trespass" onto a public area, refused to answer questions about why she wasn't furloughed.
 

Meanwhile, SEIU paid shills $15 an hour to picket the veterans.

The administration is breaking new ground, over-reaching in expanding justifications for shutting down popular tourist areas.  A passel of officials were dispatched to erect barricades (now starting to be called Barry-cades) across scenic overlooks on the George Washington Parkway, and were sent to Mount Vernon to close off that estate, despite the fact that Mount Vernon is run by a private foundation.  Likewise, a popular 17th-century farm in a Virginia park was shut down, with NPS police removing staff and volunteers, because it is associated in partnership with adjoining federal land.  The Claude Moore Colonial Farm has never been effected before, and it derives the totality of its income from fees and programs, thus the shutdown here imposed for the first time threatens to close the site permanently. 

There was an initial concern that the pay of the military would be effected, but Obama announced on Monday that military pay would not be withheld, in response to one of the bills that the Republicans are putting forth to finance the vital parts of the government.  Yet two years ago, with a threat of a looming shutdown, he threatened just that, along with a withholding of Social Security payments.  So which is it?  Either we are compelled by law and procedure to delay the pay of our military, or not – he can't have it both ways.  That is, unless his reaction to either case discloses his typical imperial penchant of blithely choosing which laws to obey or disregard. 

There are also the silly web site warnings that they are inaccessible due to the shutdown.  Of course they're accessible, just like mine has been available during my recent absence – you click onto it, and it's there.  This is like the government claiming that you can unprint a book, unless they expect us to believe that some apparatchik is powering the site by some organ-grinder crank handle. 

Even military cemeteries on foreign soil, like the one at Normandy, are now being closed for the first time.  Sure, you can probably cite some petty legal distinction that some could interpret to try to justify and excuse the extreme punishment to those who have saved for their whole life to visit the sacred place of rest of a loved one, but these examples are just part and parcel of the small-minded viciousness that underlie this circus, and they do not address the question of why, after all the past examples, are all these other sites both here and abroad being shut down in this particular 'man-caused disaster'.

"Gentlemen, you see that in the anarchy in which we live, society manages much as before.  Take care, if your disputes last too long, that the people do not come to think that they can very easily do without us."  --Benjamin Franklin, Constitutional Convention 1787

*****
Update: There are now reports that the Barry-cades are being tied together with wire instead of police tape to hinder people moving them and to keep the public from entering public land.

I can understand that if you send the clerk home from the bookstore at the Cascade-Siskiyou National Monument, then close the bookstore.  But to shut down the entire area?  These are public parks, which belong to the people, not the government, and most certainly not to the administration.  We should take as an example the World War II veterans, and simply occupy these public areas as we see fit, in a demonstration of civil disobedience.

I suggest a run on wire-cutters, available at practically any hardware store for about $10 and up, and carry a pair in your back pocket.  (I trust that Texas will make exception to its law.)  This is just in case you run up against a federal obstacle to the public.

*****
Update: While the list of questionable closures adds up, we find that there are exceptions for parks near Democrat legislators, as well as Obama's favorite golf course at Andrews AFB.

And what about National Public Radio?  Shouldn't that be shut down for the interim?  Democrats could always switch to MSNBC, which would at least give them an audience.  I wouldn't be surprised if Al Jazeera America passed them in the ratings.  (H/T: John Lock)

*****
Update: From Day by Day:


 

Saturday, September 21, 2013

Off the Grid (2013)

The original idea was the Canadian Rockies and the coast of British Columbia, but weather in that region is driving us to the southwest instead, mostly outdoors (below is our goal) but the occasional city stop for refreshment (I understand that Las Vegas has some interesting libations - in the sublime to the ridiculous spectrum of our journey) and attending to gear.


Attending to my web log will be even more intermittent in the meantime, but I look forward to a return.

Friday, September 20, 2013

We Invite the Mentally Ill To Strike Us

In my current vocation, that being a corrections counselor, I deal with a criminal population which includes perforce the mentally ill within their midst.  It is from this present experience that I find the topic as explained by Dr Charles Krauthammer (political commentator extraordinaire and former psychiatrist) to be particularly supportive.  (The appeal that Krauthammer has to me extends well beyond this subject, but I will limit it to this story for the moment.)


Krauthammer's latest article deals with the clear mental instability of Aaron Alexis and how it applies to his slaughter of twelve innocent victims at the Washington Navy Yard, and the studied disregard to such cases where massacres can be avoided.  I commend it to you for its Occam-like quality. 

He writes of a psychotic break that Alexis had in Newport, Rhode Island last month, wherein the police responded and then departed, unable to do anything other than to recommend that he get some sleep. Krauthammer then gives an example of what would have happened if Alexis were brought to him in his capacity of the psychiatrist on duty at the ER of the Massachusetts General Hospital in 1978, which would have resulted in care up to and including commitment:
That's what a compassionate society does.  It would no more abandon this man to fend for himself than it would a man suffering a stroke.  And as a side effect, that compassion might even extend to potential victims of his psychosis – in the event, remote but real, that he might someday burst into some place of work and kill 12 innocent people….
I know the civil libertarian arguments.  I know that involuntary commitment is outright paternalism.  But paternalism is essential for children because they don't have a fully developed rational will.  Do you think Alexis was in command of his will that night in Newport?
We cannot, of course, be cavalier about commitment.  We should have layers of review, albeit rapid.  But it's both cruel and reckless to turn loose people as lost and profoundly suffering as Alexis, even apart from any potential dangerousness.
More than half of those sleeping on grates have suffered mental illness.  It's a national scandal.  It's time we recalibrated the pendulum that today allows the mentally ill to die with their rights on – and, rarely but unforgivably, take a dozen innocents with them.

Thursday, September 19, 2013

Hold On. This Will Be A Bumpy Ride.

Photo-shopped, but in the one picture/thousand words category, this does well to sum up the relationship between Vladimir Putin and our own Obama, particularly as the world sees them in comparison (click):


Passed along by Gerard Vanderleun.  And incidentally, it's been a while since I spent a good amount of time in the saddle (and none on a Mongolian pony), but Putin's grip on the reins seems a bit severe.  Maybe some control issues?

Our press jokes about the photo events that are staged for Putin's benefit, but they miss the point that for the Russians and a good number of other people in the world, it works. 

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

Journalist Guide to Firearms Reporting

As a public service, allow me to pass along this input by way of Doug Ross, which nails down a journalist's perspective when reporting on firearms (click to embiggen):

 
This helps explain the front page of the New York Daily News that dashed right past the actual story of the shooter at the Washington Navy Yard in favor of trying to score a political point (talk about burying the lede):
 
"Never mind"
 
I'm sure it looked really great to those who really wanted the victims to be slain with the bête noire of the anti-gun lobby, but unfortunately for them, there was no AR-15 used by Aaron Alexis (other than the one wielded by the officer who finally took him out).  The story is in need of what we would term the Litella Defense (which is no defense at all), assuming that the NYDN actually had a defense.
 
 
It mumbled the usual claptrap about reliable sources being wrong, but all that really meant was that the paper didn't have the professional integrity to secure corroborating evidence before it ran the story.  It took them two days to admit their negligence, giving the story a chance to gain a purchase among the low information voters that mull over such dross during their union bus ride to the voting polls.